The price of oil edged up again yesterday (Tuesday), before settling at $137
a barrel flat, as concerns about short-term supplies continues to overwhelm
Saudi Arabia’s recent pledge to boost production. With Saudi Arabia offering
some, albeit limited, cooperation, Congress has turned its ire on speculators
and investment banks.
First, demand from China and India was to blame for soaring oil prices. Then
the weak dollar, the member nations of OPEC, Big Oil, and now investment banks
take their turn in the rotation as politicians scramble to find a suitable
scapegoat in an election year.
Lawmakers have introduced nine different bills concerning speculation in the
oil market. Four separate hearings have been scheduled for this week, including
Monday’s hearing before the House Energy and Commerce Committee concerning foreign trade
regulation.
"I have dark suspicions about the effects that unchecked speculation and
possible market manipulation are having on the price of crude oil and petroleum
products," Committee Chairman John Dingell said. "Congress should act to
determine the precise effects that manipulation and speculation are having on
energy prices, and work to identify where there are gaps in regulation that
allow this rampant speculation."
Dingell suggested Congress set firm limits on the size of energy speculators’
positions, require full disclosure of all energy trading from investment banks,
and prevent pension funds from investing in commodities to diversify their
holdings.
Five of the nine proposed bills involve the regulation of foreign oil
trading. Some proposals would allow only American investors to trade oil on
regulated exchanges, while others would have the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading
Commission collect data from foreign trade boards.
For support, the committee turned to a panel of energy-market participants
who testified that tighter regulation of the market would take the air out of
oil prices.
"We’re not talking about [an oil price] bubble; we’re talking about a tumor,"
said Michael Masters, of Masters Capital Management. "It grows and grows, and
it’s hurtful as it expands. But now we have discovered the tumor and we should
take it out immediately."
Masters said that proper regulation of oil futures trading would cut prices
back down to $70 a barrel in 30 days.
"I firmly believe that the current record oil price in excess of $135 per
barrel is inflated," Fadel Gheit, managing director and senior oil analyst at
Oppenheimer & Co. (OPY), said. "I believe, based on supply and demand fundamentals,
crude oil prices should not be above $60 per barrel."
Afterwards, Rep.