By relaxing the U.S. financial system’s mark-to-market accounting standards,
the U.S. government is effectively deactivating the financial “early warning
system” that let investors know that a global credit crisis was brewing – and
kept it from turning into a total global meltdown, professional investors
warn.
As part of the just-passed U.S. bailout bill, the government has reiterated the
Securities and Exchange Commission’s authority to relax the mark-to-market
standards. If the SEC actually follows through on that directive, many
professional investors worry that we won’t catch on to the next leg of the
ongoing credit crisis until it’s way too late.
While politicians point to mark-to-market rules as the cause of the billions
in write-downs and losses suffered by financial firms in recent quarters, in
fact, it was mark-to-market accounting that first exposed the underlying
problems in the complex markets for mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and credit-default swaps (CDS).
“Mark-to-market is reality-based accounting,” said Money
Morning Contributing Editor Shah Gilani in a phone interview
yesterday (Tuesday). “Anything else requires a looking glass and a ticket to
Wonderland.”
“To me, mark-to-market accounting is the clarion sound of beagles barking,
letting transparency hunters know down which dark hole the fox is hiding,” said
Gilani, a former hedge-fund manager who recently penned a five-part
investigative series on the U.S. credit crisis – including an alternate bailout plan that he says would’ve cost taxpayers
very little.
Without the early warnings raised by mark-to-market accounting standards, the
problems in the CDS market could have gone unnoticed for much longer, leaving no
time to hedge or prepare for the ultimate carnage to the financial sector.
“In the past couple of weeks, fair-value accounting has
been under attack,” JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM) analyst Dane Mott wrote in a recent report,
Bloomberg News reported. “Blaming fair-value
accounting for the credit crisis is a lot like going to a doctor for a diagnosis
and then blaming him for telling you that you are sick.”
Prior to the current credit mess, mortgage-backed securities were priced
according to Markit’s ABX Index, which used the average weight of four
series in the index to track the price of housing derivatives. But once the
subprime market collapsed, the ABX Index plunged - and has yet to recover.
Mark-to-market accounting standards kicked off a round of write-downs at
global financial firms that highlighted the overexposure of many to these risky
securities. Without such standards, investors would have been unaware of the
coming credit crunch.
The Rise of Fair Value
Mark-to-market accounting, or fair-value accounting as it is
sometimes called, arose partly in response to the U.S. Savings & Loan Crisis of the late 1980s and early
1990s.