This article was published on RealMoney on February 1, just 4 hours before MicroStrategy surprised investors with a blown earnings report. Although I typically take a long-term view, you can never count on having the luxury to do so.
Looking at my screens this week, I noticed that MicroStrategy’s (MSTR) Zacks rank had jumped from 2 to 1, a rank that puts the company’s earnings revision momentum among the top 5% of companies ranked. Looking further, I found that estimates for both 2007 (yet to be reported) and 2008 had been hiked by more than $0.25 per share in the last 90 days.
Meanwhile, the stock has declined from $110 to $72 during the same period. A declining stock amid rising earnings estimates was something I had to investigate further. Upon doing so, however, my conclusion is that there may still be further downside in the shares.
One thing that has buoyed software stocks in recent years has been the consolidation wave. According to company filings, MicroStrategy “competitors that are primarily focused on business intelligence products include, among others, Actuate (ACTU), Business Objects (BOBJ), Cognos (COGN), Information Builders and the SAS Institute.”
Cognos is being acquired by International Business Machines (IBM - Annual Report) and Business Objects by SAP AG (SAP - Annual Report). Another competitor, Hyperion, was already bought by Oracle. It is increasingly looking like MicroStrategy is among the wallflowers at this dance.
And without an acquisition, things aren’t looking so hot fundamentally. A look at recent customer wins shows a concentration of retail, financial and healthcare markets. Not exactly the clients one wants during a consumer and financial crunch.
Indeed, it looks as though the toll was already being felt when MicroStrategy reported third-quarter results. Although gross accounts receivable were basically flat during the first nine months of 2007, the allowance for doubtful accounts was increased by nearly 50% to $2.8 million.