After receiving hundreds of billions of dollars in taxpayer-funded federal
bailout money, the biggest U.S. banks say they can’t track how that money is
being spent.
Some of the banks are outright refusing to discuss the matter, a
new study has found.
"We have not disclosed that to the public. We’re declining to," Thomas Kelly,
a spokesman for JP Morgan Chase & Co. (JPM) told The
Associated Press, which
surveyed 21 banks that received at least $1 billion in federal bailout money,
and asked how that capital was being used. JP Morgan received a $25 billion
infusion as part of the U.S. Treasury Department’s $700 billion Troubled
Assets Relief Program (TARP).
As an ongoing Money Morning investigation has
demonstrated, billions in U.S.
bank rescue funds are financing buyouts worldwide - instead of lending at
home. Some of those buyouts deals are being done in markets as
far away as China. Meanwhile, credit remains tight here in the U.S. market,
a situation that could be alleviated if only the banks made the bailout money
available to consumers in the form of loans.
Money Morning was one of the first news
organizations to really examine how TARP money was being misdirected, and wasn’t being
deployed as originally intended. More recently, The
AP has joined the journalistic posse and published several
investigative pieces, including one that looked at executive
pay at financial institutions that received bailout money.
Some experts - such as investing icon Jim Rogers - say that bailouts in
general are bad deals. They’re even worse if they’re funded by taxpayers who
don’t know how their money is being spent [A related story on Rogers'
views about the U.S. banking-bailout initiative appeared last week in Money
Morning. To access that story, please click
here].
The bottom line: Banks won’t say how they’re using
the bailout money. That refusal - coupled with the almost non-existent
disclosure and oversight of the TARP program - means the country may well never
find out how hundreds of billions of taxpayer dollars were spent.
Anatomy of a Survey
In its latest investigative offering, The Associated
Press contacted 21 banks that received at least $1 billion in
government money and asked four questions: How much has been spent? What was it
spent on? How much is being held in savings? And what’s the plan for the
rest?
According to The AP, none of the banks provided
specific answers.
For instance, when Kevin Heine, a spokesman for Bank of New York Mellon Corp.
(BK) - which
received about $3 billion in TARP money - was asked how his institution was
using the emergency infusion, he replied by stating that "we have not disclosed
that to the public. We’re declining to."
The words varied, but the basic message was the same from one bank to
another. For instance, Barry Koling, a spokesman for SunTrust Banks Inc.