In mid November, Bank of American Corp. (BAC) ponied up more than $7
billion to nearly double its already existing investment in the state-owned China
Construction Bank Corp., a move that gave the biggest U.S. bank a 19% stake
in China’s second-largest lender.
Less than two months later, however, BofA sold $2.8 billion of its shares in
the Beijing-based China Construction Bank, a jarring about face made necessary
by the U.S. bank’s need to raise cash.
And Bank of America isn’t the only Western lender making such a move.
Just this week, the Royal Bank of Scotland Group PLC (ADR: RBS), Great Britain’s biggest
government-controlled bank, sold its $2.3 billion stake in the Bank of China
Ltd. (Pink: BACHF), the No. 3 Chinese
lender - also because RBS needed to replenish its capital position. That stake
represented 4.3% of the Bank of China’s outstanding shares.
RBS, BofA and UBS AG (UBS) - all early “strategic
investors” in China’s biggest banks - have now each trimmed their investments in
those banks, thanks to the expiration of restrictive “lockup periods.” UBS said
last month that it had sold its entire 1.33% stake in the Bank of China.
More
divestitures are expected.
“Undoubtedly, foreign
banks will continue to expand their footprints in China,” Zhao Xijun, deputy
director of the School of Finance at Renmin University of China, told
The Wall Street Journal. “But they will be more
focused on developing their own businesses, rather than buying a Chinese
lender.”
Cash-strapped Western banks - desperate to raise money in the face of the
worst financial crisis since the Great Depression - are paring their stakes in
top China banks. That will bring in needed capital today but at the cost of lost
future profits tomorrow in an economy that’s the world’s fastest-growing, and a
market in which a burgeoning middle class figures to create all sorts of
lucrative businesses for players with the ability to stay in the game.
On China’s end, the divestitures are forcing Beijing to reassess its strategy
of using foreign know-how to assemble a world-class banking system.
Since 2005, foreign financial institutions such as Bank of America and the
RBS have pumped more than $25 billion into Chinese banks as part of a
high-dollar game of quid pro quo engineered by the Red Dragon’s regulators:
Foreign investors would gain access to China’s banking market, and in return
would show China’s banks how to make money in a free-market environment.
As these developments demonstrate, the global financial crisis continues to
worsen, meaning the bailout strategies used so far haven’t had the desired
benefit. BofA received a $15 billion infusion from the U.S. Treasury
Department’s $250 billion “recapitalization” effort. The Edinburgh-based RBS
received $29 billion in bailout money of its own after taking $10.2 billion in
write-downs in 2008.
As a Money Morning investigation has demonstrated,
many U.S. banks
used bailout money to go on a global shopping spree, instead of retiring bad
debts or boosting lending to businesses and consumers. The payback has been
rather quick in some cases.
As the divestments have now demonstrated, the worsening financial crisis is
forcing financial institutions to sell promising assets, and to do so at a point
when the value of those holdings is probably at or near their nadir.
“For RBS, they don’t really have much choice,” Samuel Chen, a Hong Kong-based
analyst at JPMorgan Chase & Co. (JPM), told
Bloomberg News. “They would probably rather hold
it.”
Indeed, as one analyst said, Western banks are selling out at prices where
they should actually be buying.
“Although the selling by foreign strategic investors may put some short-term
pressure on prices, bank
stocks are undervalued given their long-term growth prospects,” Zhang
Xi, a Beijing-based analyst at China Galaxy Securities Co., told
Bloomberg News.. “Now is a good time to buy Bank of
China and other big lenders.”
Goldman Sachs Group Inc. (GS) still owns 16.5
billion shares in Industrial & Commercial Bank of China, the world’s largest
bank by market value, and has agreed not to sell the shares until after April
28, according to published reports. American Express Co. (AXP) and Allianz SE (ADR: AZ) are
among the Commercial Bank of China’s other U.S.