Highlighted stocks include Forest Labortatories, Inc. (FRX), McKesson Corporation (MCK), Monsanto Company (MON), Caterpillar, Inc. (CAT) and ConocoPhillips (COP).
Key Points:
- Fourth-quarter reports remain ugly, total net income for the 184 companies reporting so far is -43.7% versus a year ago
- The surprise ratio of 1.73:1 and the median surprise of 2.30% are both below "normal"
- Financials red ink so far is almost 7x year ago levels.
- Excluding Financials, total earnings are down 16.9%
- Fourth-quarter total net income is now expected to be -31.9%
- Trends continue to be terrible, 2009 expectations fell 6.64% in a week
- Estimate cuts running more than 5:1 over increases for both 2009 and 2010
- Total net income in 2009 now expected to fall 5.5%, following 12.9% 2008 decline
- P/Es based on 2009 estimates will prove to be to low as "E" plunges
- Bottom up estimate for S&P 500 now $66.60 in 2009, down from $69.04 on Tuesday and $71.34 a week ago, I expect it to be less than $60.
Total Net Income Growth
- The returns are very ugly, the 184 that have reported are showing earnings of just $44.5B aggregate versus total earnings of $79.1B a year ago and $89.5B in the third-quarter
- Already reported firms down 43.7% in fourth quarter, remaining firms expected to be down 22.0%
- Total net income expected to fall 31.9% in the fourth quarter from a year ago, was -29.0% a week ago
- Negative year-over-year growth in 4Q now expected for 7 sectors
- Health Care and Utilities only sectors reporting higher income so far
- Energy, Materials and Discretionary all expected to be down over 40% last quarter
- Financials gushing red ink
- Full year net income in 2009 expected to be down 5.5% from 2008 levels, following a 12.9% decline in 2008
- First quarter total net income now expected to be 22.3% below 1Q08, was -15.1% on Tuesday, and -13.7 a week ago
- Early 2010 expectations looks for 21.1% growth over 2009
- Index changes mask size of earnings decline in 2008 (Merrill Lynch, Wachovia, National City and AIG gone)
| Total Net Income Growth (Reported) |
| Sector |
Q2 '08 A |
Q3 '08 A |
Q4 '08 A |
Q1 '09 E |
2007 A |
2008 A |
2009 E |
2010 E |
| Health Care |
8.26% |
5.88% |
9.59% |
-2.12% |
17.72% |
9.12% |
0.92% |
10.59% |
| Utilities |
5.33% |
-5.67% |
7.21% |
11.10% |
19.26% |
0.31% |
3.13% |
6.75% |
| Cons. Stap. |
-0.16% |
0.87% |
-8.69% |
-10.42% |
15.61% |
0.28% |
3.08% |
11.63% |
| Telecom |
7.13% |
-5.74% |
-9.85% |
-8.99% |
25.47% |
3.24% |
-1.17% |
4.77% |
| Cons. Disc. |
-7.43% |
11.32% |
-18.23% |
-21.97% |
-8.29% |
10.85% |
-6.33% |
15.01% |
| Technology |
22.26% |
12.52% |
-21.14% |
-32.19% |
16.71% |
17.10% |
-14.29% |
18.92% |
| Industrials |
4.98% |
-1.91% |
-22.54% |
-29.68% |
14.84% |
-1.29% |
-17.69% |
10.48% |
| Energy |
4.10% |
37.55% |
-30.69% |
-46.95% |
6.83% |
7.78% |
-41.91% |
10.79% |
| Materials |
11.36% |
10.89% |
-70.38% |
-58.66% |
16.78% |
-2.53% |
-39.96% |
34.89% |
| Financials |
-56.75% |
-70.84% |
-3251.95% |
-51.64% |
-24.49% |
-87.13% |
193.10% |
88.57% |
| S&P |
-12.15% |
-13.08% |
-43.69% |
-28.70% |
0.71% |
-17.87% |
-5.53% |
22.86% |
| Total Net Income (Reported) |
| Sector |
Q4 '08 |
Q4 '07 |
Q3 '08 |
Q3 '07 |
| Technology |
$15,809 |
$19,896 |
$17,149 |
$15,321 |
| Health Care |
$15,714 |
$14,116 |
$15,936 |
$14,974 |
| Industrials |
$10,818 |
$13,764 |
$12,127 |
$12,066 |
| Energy |
$3,965 |
$3,679 |
$4,514 |
$3,675 |
| Cons. Disc. |
$2,516 |
$2,972 |
$5,059 |
$4,415 |
| Cons. Stap. |
$2,058 |
$2,278 |
$2,150 |
$2,137 |
| Telecom |
$1,725 |
$1,782 |
$1,865 |
$1,814 |
| Utilities |
$1,268 |
$1,166 |
$1,459 |
$1,627 |
| Materials |
$654 |
$3,024 |
$4,130 |
$3,705 |
| Financials |
($18,117) |
($2,394) |
$6,300 |
$24,046 |
| S&P |
$36,409 |
$60,283 |
$70,690 |
$83,780 |
| Total Net Income Growth (Not Reported) |
| Sector |
Q2 '08 A |
Q3 '08 A |
Q4 '08 E |
Q1 '09 E |
2007 A |
2008 E |
2009 E |
2010 E |
| Financials |
-47.13% |
-133.05% |
47.65% |
78.91% |
-3.22% |
-64.30% |
95.73% |
8.72% |
| Utilities |
3.67% |
-6.11% |
25.56% |
-18.14% |
7.94% |
4.52% |
4.09% |
12.01% |
| Health Care |
9.87% |
9.35% |
4.14% |
3.85% |
23.67% |
6.61% |
7.10% |
12.61% |
| Cons. Stap. |
2.32% |
15.04% |
0.97% |
5.61% |
6.18% |
12.12% |
8.10% |
6.26% |
| Industrials |
8.22% |
5.87% |
-25.33% |
-2.71% |
2.71% |
6.81% |
-11.00% |
6.03% |
| Technology |
8.30% |
-2.66% |
-30.24% |
-23.43% |
2.80% |
11.84% |
-8.39% |
12.84% |
| Energy |
21.53% |
63.88% |
-46.18% |
-43.22% |
10.01% |
21.88% |
-37.15% |
33.61% |
| Materials |
-5.99% |
-13.63% |
-53.74% |
-40.34% |
-1.40% |
-15.74% |
-26.29% |
44.99% |
| Cons. Disc. |
Related Stories
The above story is the opinion of the author only and it does not reflect
iStockAnalyst opinion. Further, the author is not personally advising you
regarding the suitability of the story for your investment needs. In no event
iStockAnalyst will be liable for any loss or damage including without
limitation, indirect or consequential loss or damage, or any loss or damage
whatsoever arising from or arising out of, or in connection with the use of this
information. Please consult your investment advisor before making any investment
decision.