Bloomberg put up a headline this morning that I found eye-catching: "Stock Market ‘Bubble' to End, Morgan Stanley Says", http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601110&sid=a.YErMIwMYKA. Ruchir Sharma, who oversees $25 billion in emerging-market stocks at Morgan Stanley, is quoted as saying "the (global stock market) rally will end as the effects of the (government) stimulus begins to fade and the credit bubble caused by easy money disappears."
We are still learning about asset bubbles and credit bubbles so it is interesting to examine what market participants are seeing and what they are saying about the existence of bubbles and the subsequent collapse of bubbles. In this reported interview we get some insight as to how one person sees the current situation in the stock market.
"Some markets may be hurt by the diversion of government stimulus away from the economy and into stocks and other investments," Sharma states. "Central banks globally were hoping the funds would result in an increase in credit growth, driving the economy. That remains weak in most countries."
"Liquidity has found its way to the wrong assets," he said. "You can take a horse to water but can't force it to drink."
According to Sharma, what many have been talking about with respect to the United States economy is being seen around the world. Governments have spent large amounts of money attempting to stimulate their economies and the central banks in those countries have poured liquidity into their country's financial system in order to get credit flowing again.
Rather than the funds going directly into the spending flow, increasing economic activity, the funds have circuitously found their way into "stocks and other investments." The diversion of these funds into "stocks and other investments" have resulted in a substantial rise in asset prices in these areas, stock markets and commodities markets, and have left productive outlets wanting for resources.
How could this situation have evolved having just gone through three recent experiences of asset or credit bubbles, the stock market bubble of the 1990s, the "bull run," according to Sharma, "between 2003 and 2007" and the housing bubble? Don't the policymakers have any idea of the damage they can do to a financial system and economy?
In this respect, another person, Arthur Smithers, with a "deep understanding of economics and a lifetime's experience of financial markets" (See Martin Wolf"s "How Mistaken Ideas Helped to Bring the Economy Down" in the Financial Times:
http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/38164e12-c330-11de-8eca-00144feab49a.html.) has also questioned current values in stock markets.
Smithers has used "two fundamental measures of value" to determine the "fair value" of markets.