They are traded over-the-counter, usually by
telephone. They are subject to re-sale to another party willing to enter into
another contract. Most frighteningly, credit default swaps are subject to “
counterparty risk.”
If the party providing the insurance protection – once it has collected its
upfront payment and premiums – doesn’t have the money to pay the insured buyer
in the case of a default event affecting the referenced bond or loan (think
hedge funds), or if the “insurer” goes bankrupt (Bear Stearns was almost there, and American International Group
Inc. (AIG) was almost there) the buyer is not covered – period. The
premium payments are gone, as is the insurance against default.
Credit default swaps are not standardized instruments. In fact, they
technically aren’t true securities in the classic sense of the word in that
they’re not transparent, aren’t traded on any exchange, aren’t subject to
present securities laws, and aren’t regulated. They are, however, at risk – all
$62 trillion (the best guess by the ISDA) of them.
Fundamentally, this kind of derivative serves a real purpose – as a hedging
device. The actual holders, or creditors, of outstanding corporate or sovereign
loans and bonds might seek insurance to guarantee that the debts they are owed
are repaid. That’s the economic purpose of insurance.
What happened, however, is that risk speculators who wanted exposure to
certain asset classes, various bonds and loans, or security pools such as
residential and commercial mortgage-backed securities (yes, those same subprime
mortgage-backed securities that you’ve been reading about), but didn’t actually
own the underlying credits, now had a means by which to speculate on them.
If you think XYZ Corp. is in trouble, and won’t be able to pay back its
bondholders, you can speculate by buying, and paying premiums for, credit
default swaps on their bonds, which will pay you the full face amount of the
bonds if they do actually default. If, on the other hand, you think that XYZ
Corp. is doing just fine, and its bonds are as good as gold, you can offer
insurance to a fellow speculator, who holds the opinion opposite yours. That
means you’d essentially be speculating that the bonds would not default. You’re
hoping that you’ll collect, and keep, all the premiums, and never have to pay
off on the insurance. It’s pure speculation.
Credit default swaps are not unlike me being able to insure your house, not
with you, but with someone else entirely not connected to your house, so that if
your house is washed away in the next hurricane I get paid its value. I’m
speculating on an event. I’m making a bet.
The bad news is that there are even worse bets out there. There are credit
default swaps written on subprime mortgage securities.