CHICAGO, Aug. 14 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- CME Group (Nasdaq: CME) today
sent the following letter to the Class A Members of the New York Mercantile
Exchange, Inc.:
Dear NYMEX Class A Members:
We have enjoyed the opportunity to meet with a number of NYMEX members and
clearing members over the past two weeks to discuss the enhancements included
in our revised merger agreement. You should have received proxy materials
explaining these changes.
We regret that we will not have the opportunity to meet with each of you
individually prior to your August 18 special meeting. However, our
discussions with your fellow members have highlighted to us the value of
ensuring that you each have further insight into the potential economic impact
-- both long term and short term -- of the revised transaction on your
individual circumstances.
1. CME Group will maintain a price differential in favor of NYMEX
members so long as CME or CBOT members have price preferences.
2. CME Group will maintain a membership market and will limit the Class
A memberships to the current level of 816 memberships. We believe
that limiting the number of memberships with floor access and
trading and brokerage privileges, maintaining a membership fee
differential and adopting a more flexible membership eligibility
program should enhance the overall value of the NYMEX membership you
are retaining.
3. We also believe our business plan has created significant membership
value and opportunity. We have adopted member pricing policies that
incentivize high volume participants and have promoted the benefits
of that pricing to hedge funds, proprietary trading shops and
financial institutions. Approximately 60 hedge funds and 20
proprietary trading shops have joined CME as either members or
clearing members in the period following demutualization and
purchased a significant number of memberships. The increased
participation of these key market participants has improved and
deepened the liquidity of CME's current products and benefited all
users of our markets as well as increased demand for CME
memberships. At the time of our demutualization, the combination
of the CME membership and the embedded equity value was worth
$525,000. Currently, the value of the CME membership alone is $1.2
million. While there are no guarantees, we believe this successful
approach would benefit the NYMEX product set as well.
4. The $750,000 payment represents the fair value to extinguish
significant membership rights, including the 311(G) rights and other
trading rights and protections. This payment establishes certainty
and immediacy for an economic value that is currently highly
uncertain as to both its timing and its ultimate value.
5. The $750,000 payment will not extinguish the NYMEX membership. Your
NYMEX membership will have rights in addition to the pricing
differential. Those rights include trading floor access -- to the
current trading floor facility for a number of years and to a
NY-based trading floor for as long as such floor satisfies basic
profitability tests, the right to sell or lease the Class A
membership, account based fees for NYMEX members, the right to
authorize three individuals with power of attorney to trade your
account at member rates, and protections against CME moving pits
from New York to Chicago over NYMEX member objections or until a
significant waiting period has passed. Some of these rights and
protections are specific to NYMEX members and not available to CME
or CBOT members.