IRVING, Texas, Oct. 30 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Commercial Metals Company
(NYSE: CMC) today reported net earnings of $232.0 million or $1.97 per diluted
share on net sales of $10.4 billion for the year ended August 31, 2008. This
compares with net earnings of $355.4 million or $2.92 per diluted share on net
sales of $8.3 billion last year. The annual results included after-tax LIFO
expense of a record $209 million or $1.78 per diluted share. This compares
with after-tax LIFO expense of $33.3 million or $0.27 per diluted share last
year. At year end, our LIFO reserve totaled $562 million. LIFO is an inventory
costing method that assumes the most recent inventory purchases or goods
manufactured are sold first which in periods of rising prices results in an
expense that eliminates inflationary profits from net income. Changes in LIFO
are not write-downs, write-offs or market adjustments. They are changes in
cost components based on an assumption of inventory flows.
Fourth quarter net earnings were $63.5 million or $0.55 per diluted share
on net sales of $3.1 billion. This compares with $104.7 million or $0.86 per
diluted share on net sales of $2.3 billion for the fourth quarter last year.
The current year quarter included a record after-tax LIFO expense of $90.9
million or $0.78 per diluted share compared with after-tax LIFO income of $5.7
million or $0.05 per diluted share in last year's fourth quarter.
Management had projected an earnings range of $0.90 to $1.00 per diluted
share assuming no LIFO effect for the quarter. Actual earnings per diluted
share were $0.55 with a LIFO expense of $0.78 per diluted share.
Operationally, the Company exceeded its projection by a range of $0.33 to
$0.43 per diluted share. The LIFO expense arose from fourth quarter surges in
scrap purchase costs. These costs were still in scrap inventories and as a
component of finished goods at year end. There were also significant
inventories in transit for our domestic steel marketing business.
Selling, general and administrative expenses in the fourth quarter
included $10.6 million of costs associated with the investment in the global
deployment of SAP software compared to $9.4 million in last year's fourth
quarter. For the year ended August 31, 2008, the amount expensed was $53.7
million as compared to $33.8 million last year; project to date we have
expensed $88.7 million. Other SAP costs of $83.1 million have been capitalized
since inception of the project, of which $49.9 million has been capitalized in
the current year and $13.9 million in the current quarter.
The effective tax rate for the quarter was 22.8% compared with last year's
26.6%, and for the whole year was 31.1% compared with fiscal 2007 at 31.9%.
The lower rate was due to a geographic shift in earnings (higher profits in
Poland which has a lower tax rate).
General Conditions
Murray R. McClean, Chairman, President and CEO, said, 'The quarter
continued the upward volatility in ferrous scrap pricing, and steel finished
goods pricing outpaced ferrous scrap pricing resulting in metal margin
expansion. Management had anticipated a softening of ferrous scrap prices
which did occur, but not until the end of the quarter. The increased prices
plus in-transit inventories led to yet another enormous LIFO charge. The
record LIFO expense of $0.78 per diluted share was the third quarterly record
in succession. Though the LIFO charge affords the Company a significant tax
deferral, it does mask the underlying strong markets. The continued upward
trend in metal pricing propelled our Americas Recycling segment to an all-time
quarterly earnings record. For the second quarter in succession, the Americas
Mills segment had increases in tons melted, rolled, and shipped. Continually
escalating prices waylaid the Americas Fabrication and Distribution operations
with a staggering LIFO charge and further margin compression. In the
International Mills segment, our mill in Poland was the star performer while
we continued the turnaround in Croatia. Our International Fabrication and
Distribution segment set an all-time fourth quarter earnings record.'
Americas Recycling
According to McClean, 'Adjusted operating profit of $52.9 million
represented the second consecutive time the segment set an all-time quarterly
earnings record. It was aided by a small pre-tax LIFO income of $5.1 million
compared to LIFO income of $9.3 million in last year's fourth quarter. Ferrous
scrap prices advanced during the quarter, peaking in July and beginning to
tail by quarter end. Pricing was supported by continued strong international
demand, record iron ore prices, and reduced prime scrap availability due to a
slowdown in U.S. manufacturing. Ferrous operations accounted for almost 90% of
the segment's profitability. The average ferrous scrap sales price for the
fourth quarter compared to last year's fourth quarter increased $233 per short
ton to $450 per short ton, while shipments (including the units that formerly
were reported under the old Domestic Mills segment) increased 11% to 782
thousand tons. Nonferrous pricing advanced a more modest 7% compared to the
prior year fourth quarter, but was dropping as the quarter ended. Chinese
demand weakened during the quarter and, combined with a rebounding U.S.
dollar, drove nonferrous shipments down 14% to 79 thousand tons versus last
year's fourth quarter. We exported 33% of our nonferrous scrap material during
the quarter.'
Americas Mills
McClean said, 'With demand strong and scrap prices rising, our Americas
Mills segment's tons melted, rolled, and shipped all exceeded last year's
fourth quarter. Prices increased each month of the quarter (softening only in
late August) leading to a pre-tax LIFO expense of $40.2 million compared to
income of $135 thousand in the prior year fourth quarter.
'Our steel mills adjusted operating profit of $45.1 million was down 14.7%
compared to the prior year fourth quarter on the heels of a $41.5 million pre-
tax LIFO expense compared to a negligible amount last year. Metal margins were
11% higher at $390 per ton, necessary to keep pace with higher costs for
utilities, freight, and alloys. The price of ferrous scrap consumed rose a
stunning 87% compared to last year. Our average selling price was up $247 per
ton to $838 per ton while the average selling price for finished goods was up
$227 per ton to $866 per ton. Margins were affected by a 131% increase in
alloys and an 86% increase in energy. Combined, these two additional costs
accounted for another $29.8 million in costs this quarter compared to the
fourth quarter of last year. Sales volumes increased 15.1% to 631 thousand
tons. Rebar shipments rose 29%, and merchant tonnage rose 6%. Included in the
sales volumes were 120 thousand tons of billets of which 22 thousand tons were
exported. Total export tonnage was 33 thousand tons. The price premium of
merchant bar over reinforcing bar averaged $158 per ton. On a quarter-to-
quarter basis, tonnage melted for the fourth quarter was up 34% to 618
thousand tons while tonnage rolled was 546 thousand tons, an increase of 45%.
During the quarter we received the last required environmental permits that
allowed us to begin construction of our micro mill project in Arizona and to
date have invested $63 million of the expected $165 million total cost. Hot
commissioning is expected in September 2009.
'Our copper tube mill reported an adjusted operating profit of $4.1
million, substantially below last year's $11.1 million as slowing demand and
sliding prices took their toll. The mill recorded a pre-tax LIFO income of
$1.3 million compared to a pre-tax expense of $636 thousand in last year's
fourth quarter. Pounds shipped fell 8% to 12.8 million pounds. The average
copper selling price decreased 12 cents to $4.53 per pound and metal spreads
fell 69 cents per pound. The cost of copper scrap decreased 57 cents to $3.67
per pound. Copper tube production decreased 35% to 9.7 million pounds compared
to last year's fourth quarter.'
Americas Fabrication & Distribution
McClean added, 'The segment continued to suffer the negative consequences
of rapid upward price escalation -- titanic LIFO charges and margin
compression. Adjusted operating loss was $68 million compared to $36.1 million
income in last year's fourth quarter. Pre-tax LIFO expense was $100.9 million,
a quarterly charge for one segment larger than any consolidated year's expense
in CMC's history, sinking the profitability for the quarter. The comparable
LIFO number last year was income of $0.4 million. The composite average fab
selling price (excluding stock and buyouts) increased 7% to $1,146 a ton, not
enough to match the increase in steel finished goods prices compared to the
backlog pricing as we entered the quarter. When considering operations absent
the enormous LIFO charge, our construction services, structural fabrication,
and post plants had improved earnings over last year's fourth quarter; rebar
fabrication profitability fell slightly, but joist and deck were off
substantially. The bright spot for the segment was our domestic steel import
and distribution operations that saw a significant increase in profitability
compared to last year on the strength of strong contributions from pipe, SBQ,
and flat rolled.