(Source: The Arizona Daily Star)

By Rhonda Bodfield, The Arizona Daily Star, Tucson
Nov. 18--Even as the governor continues to push for a sales tax increase
to help erase some of the state's red ink, a new report shows Arizona has a
30-year trend toward more heavy reliance on sales taxes.
On the spending side of the ledger, university funding has plummeted over
that time while spending on prisons has doubled. Health and welfare spending
also has seen a big jump. And although a lot of attention has focused on
cutting school budgets this year, funding for kindergarten through 12th grade
has been flat over the decades.
A historical look at revenue and spending priorities over the past three
decades was released Tuesday at the "Governing Arizona" economic conference in
Phoenix. The event was designed to encourage state policymakers to come up
with bipartisan solutions to the state's somber fiscal problems.
The forum, sponsored by the Thomas R. Brown Foundations and The
Communications Institute along with other partners, including the Arizona
Daily Star, was intended to frame a big-picture discussion for state leaders,
starting with how the state gets its money and where it spends those dollars.
Arizona faces a $2 billion shortfall in its current budget. The next year
is expected to be worse, with a projected $3 billion hole.
Public-policy consultant Alan Maguire found the sales tax was the largest
source of tax revenue in 1980, accounting for 47 percent of general fund
revenues. Over the years, the tax was removed from food and the rate was
raised. The net result is that sales taxes now contribute 56 percent of the
general fund "pie."
The other big shift came from property taxes, which accounted for 6
percent of general fund in 1980. For the state, that take is all but zeroed
out now.
Income taxes, both individual and corporate, went from 34 percent to 37
percent. As a share of the state budget, however, corporate income tax dipped
from 9 percent 30 years ago to 7 percent today.
University of Arizona economist Marshall Vest said the analysis should
set off some warning bells.
Sales taxes might be politically expedient, he said, because consumers
don't see one big bill at the end of the year the way they do for property or
income taxes, but it's fairly volatile, climbing and dipping with consumer
confidence.
The most stable tax systems rely on three components, he said -- taxes on
income; taxes on wealth, largely through property; and taxes on transactions.
"The state is highly over-reliant on the sales tax. It doesn't use the
property tax at all, so you see this three-legged stool is quite unbalanced.