Join        Login             Stock Quote

Plaintiffs Appeal Proshares Court Victory

 November 13, 2012 11:47 AM

The ProShares lawsuit victory in defending the risk and operating disclosures of its inverse and leveraged exchange-traded funds (ETFs) may be short-lived as an appeal is in progress. The lawsuit was decided in favour of ProShares in New York's Southern District Court, in September.

Jacob Zamansky, co-lead attorney in the intended class action lawsuit in which 32 investors sued ProShares, its executives, its underwriter and independent trustees, has confirmed to SRP that an appeal is now in progress.

An "intent to appeal" the 7 September decision by New York Southern District's Court Judge John G. Koeltl, was filed on 3 October. The full appeal will be filed in a District appellate court within the next few weeks, Zamansky confirmed.

[Related -Market Needed a Yellen Bump and Didn't Get It.]

"We believe the judge gave too narrow a reading to the (ETF's) materials and to the law," Zamansky told SRP. "We think the judge got this wrong." The appeal will focus on what Zamansky called the "Grand Canyon doctrine."

"If someone tells me there's a hole in the ground but I find the Grand Canyon, it is apparent there should have been a better, larger warning," he said.

A spate of lawsuits, originally filed as early as 5 August 2009, charged that ProShares misled prospective investors in its inverse and leverage ETFs by not providing the proper and necessary disclosures.

The complaints alleged that the regulatory-required registration statements for the ProShares ETF's did not warn investors that the funds were meant as a one-day trading vehicle rather than a long-term directional bet; that they inherently carried the likelihood of a "spectacular tracking error;" and that high market volatility would cause severe consequences to returns, amongst other complaints.

[Related -Will The Sluggish US Housing Market Perk Up This Year?]

The lawsuits alleged that although some risk disclosures were present, they were completely inadequate. "…ProShares' ‘greater than one-day' risk disclosure is tantamount to a kennel selling a dog that is a cat, while disclosing that the dog may have defects," one of the lawsuits charged.

In April 2010, individual lawsuits were consolidated into one and allowed to proceed.

In the September decision handed down by Judge Koeltl, he noted that the ETF documents clearly stated, "(T)he funds do not seek to achieve their stated investment objective over a period of time greater than one day because mathematical compounding prevents the funds from achieving such results." He added, "(A) registration statement need not disclose every possible permutation of the risk, nor predict the precise manner in which the risks will manifest themselves." Rather, "…the standard is whether a reasonably prudent investor, having read the (registration) statement, would have understood the specific risks at issue."

A spokesman for ProShares, headquartered in Bethesda, Maryland, pointed SRP to the firm's earlier public comments. "We have maintained since the beginning of this case that the allegations were wholly without merit, and we are pleased that the claims have been dismissed in their entirety," said ProShares general counsel, Amy Doberman. "ProShares has demonstrated a long-standing commitment to educating investors about our products and their risks and benefits, so it is gratifying that Judge Koeltl's ruling rests on the strength and quality of our disclosures."

By Lori Pizzani

Published at StructuredRetailProducts.com

iOnTheMarket Premium


Post Comment -- Login is required to post message
Alert for new comments:
Your email:
Your Website:

rss feed

Latest Stories

article imageWill The Sluggish US Housing Market Perk Up This Year?

Housing remains a weak spot for the US economy, as suggested by yesterday’s news of a bigger-than-expected read on...

article imageThe Only Homebuilders To Own Right Now

Now is the time to invest in the housing market, but you must be read on...

article imageUS Economic Growth Slows in Q4

US GDP growth fell short of expectations in last year’s fourth quarter, the government reports. National read on...

article imageReversals After a Gap on the Open Could Mean Anything

Yesterday stock indexes gapped up on the open but then reversed course to close sharply lower. This type of read on...

Popular Articles

Daily Sector Scan
Partner Center

Related Articles:

The Only Homebuilders To Own Right Now
More Articles on: Utilities

Fundamental data is provided by Zacks Investment Research, and Commentary, news and Press Releases provided by YellowBrix and Quotemedia.
All information provided "as is" for informational purposes only, not intended for trading purposes or advice. iStockAnalyst.com is not an investment adviser and does not provide, endorse or review any information or data contained herein.
The blog articles are opinions by respective blogger. By using this site you are agreeing to terms and conditions posted on respective bloggers' website.
The postings/comments on the site may or may not be from reliable sources. Neither iStockAnalyst nor any of its independent providers is liable for any informational errors, incompleteness, or delays, or for any actions taken in reliance on information contained herein. You are solely responsible for the investment decisions made by you and the consequences resulting therefrom. By accessing the iStockAnalyst.com site, you agree not to redistribute the information found therein.
The sector scan is based on 15-30 minutes delayed data. The Pattern scan is based on EOD data.